Thing 16: YouTube vs Vimeo
Like most people out there I’ve seen lots of YouTube videos, shared by friends or searched for myself, they are part of modern day life. In fact one of my friends is known to get a bit YouTube happy after he’s had a drink or two and will insist on people sitting down to watch his latest favourites (this is actually quite fun and nowhere near as dull as I’ve made it sound – unfortunately most are not really work suitable so I’ll refrain from sharing them with you). However, I’ve never visited Vimeo before. I had a bit of a search on both and found this cartoon about digital preservation on YouTube:
The basic message is: bit rot = bad, metadata and trusted digital repositories = good and bad digital preservation could lead to nuclear holocaust, sort of. It’s a fun way to get across some basic principles of digital preservation and could potentially be used in advocacy presentations for a bit of light relief. It really is quite hard to make digital preservation fun!
I didn’t find that Vimeo had the same range of results when I did a bit of searching but I did find this video from Australasia which looks at what people can do with their own digital files at home:
My initial impressions are that whilst YouTube has much more content, the Vimeo videos are better produced and look a lot more professional. I’d be concerned if I was contributing a video that people wouldn’t really search for it on Vimeo whereas YouTube would be the first port of call for most people. This might be just my preconceptions as I haven’t used Vimeo before and I wonder if once you’ve joined the Vimeo community there might be no turning back!
See my Twitter feed for another YouTube video – not strictly work related but I was shocked to read that a librarian had lost her job over it.